[IBL] change the way usage is calculated?

[Noel Steere]

Actually, I was wondering when I could submit a rule change to go back to IP for pitcher usage, as it seemed to be a problem for my Coors-based team as the season wore on.

Since I object to all PA based pitcher usage, I object to this change.

Thanks,

Noel
NYK

Sent from my iPhone

> On Mar 21, 2016, at 10:45 PM, Sean Sweda <sweda at ibl.org> wrote:
> 
> All it would change is how usage is calculated.  Right now only AB + BB count for batters, and there's the more complicated formula for pitchers (IP*3+H+BB). Changing to real PA/BF can make in-game decisions simpler when you're running close to the cutoffs. Say your pitcher is close to 133% and you bring him in to face one batter. Under the current rules that one batter could use up 0 (HBP) or 2 (GIDP) units of usage.
> 
> Playoff requirements would not change from AB+BB. Note that every player card has the relevant info at the bottom.
> 
> Sean
> < via mobile >
> 
>> On Mar 21, 2016, at 11:04 PM, Alex Campbell <arc213 at gmail.com> wrote:
>> 
>> Can you please clarify how this change will affect things by giving us an example?  For instance are we then going to be limited by PA vs LH and RH again?  because that used to be an issue, especially as we got deeper in the season.  
>> 
>> Also, will this affect playoff rules?
>> 
>> AC
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> 
>>> On Mon, Mar 21, 2016 at 6:45 PM, Sean Sweda <sweda at ibl.org> wrote:
>>> Larry's email about GRS & Venditte a few days ago got me thinking about those vs LH/RH PA totals in the boxscores generated by GRS.  It wouldn't difficult for me to add some new code to the boxscore checker to use those values to record usage.  Doing this in conjunction with the BF totals in the PITCHERS block would allow us to go to a pure PA-based usage system.  I could then write some code to pull actual MLB PAs (including SF/SH, HBP, etc) to use as 100% for the usage report.  These changes would greatly simplify in-game calculation of usage, since every PA would count (except IBB for pitchers).  The downside is that you could no longer calculate player usage directly from the actual recorded stats.
>>> 
>>> Technically this requires a Constitutional change, but we could do it as a Commissioner's edit.  There isn't a lot of time to get this in place for the upcoming season, so I only want to do the work if there's an overwhelmingly positive reaction.
>>> 
>>> So...
>>> 
>>> 1) If you prefer we continue to calculate usage based on the current formulae (AB+BB for batters, 3*IP+H+BB for pitchers) please reply to the list with your objection.  By rule a single objection would table this until it could be voted on, which means that the soonest it could be implemented is for 2017.
>>> 
>>> 2) If you think this is a good idea reply directly to me and Rusty.
>>> 
>>> If there are no objections and a significant number of people register in the affirmative I'll write the code and get it in place before the end of week 1.
>>> 
>>> FYI, a current usage report is always available at this URL:
>>> http://www.ibl.org/~sweda/cgi-bin/usage.py
>>> 
>>> Sean
>> 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.ibl.org/pipermail/members/attachments/20160321/d528e90b/attachment.html>