[IBL] IBL Mid Season Ballot proposals - discussion

Sun Aug 28 18:35:35 EDT 2022

I think I’d be in favor of both draft proposals. 
I think one of the injury rules should be adopted, leaning towards (1).
Rosters, I hate proposal (1). I don’t think it would have the intended purpose. Teams would stock up on zoids, designated baserunners, defensive specialists rather than using the spots for the bullpen. I am all in favor of proposal (2).
Trading and fatigued pitchers, no strong feelings.

> On Aug 28, 2022, at 11:13 AM, Russell Peltz <peltz38 at gmail.com> wrote:
> 
> I've assembled some of the ballot proposals people have made recently and am putting them up for discussion.  Feel free to discuss them in e-mail or on IRC and let everyone know what you think.
> 
> If you have any questions, opinions, suggestions for changes, or any additional proposals you think should be put on a ballot, bring them up.  I'd like to have a mid-season ballot ready to vote on before the season ends, so that we can decide if any changes take effect before the draft, or for the beginning of next season.
> 
> I've put the proposals in the wiki here and will update them with changes if necessary:
> https://wiki.ibl.org/dokuwiki/doku.php/2022_mid_season_ballot_proposals
> 
> ================================================================================
> DRAFT
> 
> (1)
> A proposal for draft tiers to be determined by advancing to the 
> Divisional Round of the playoffs (i.e. win the division or win the WC 
> series), similar to how only the four teams that won their WC series last 
> year were considered "playoff" teams for draft tiers.  I think this is 
> fairer to the WC loser than the current system, and could also eliminate 
> some deliberate tanking.
> 
> (2)
> Draft Calendar
> Goal: To reduce the length of lists, give owners more information as the draft 
> proceeds, and increase trading opportunities.
> 
> Proposal:  
> The proposal would move away from 24-pick rounds. Instead, each draft day would 
> cover 8 or 12 picks (except for Rounds 8 and 9, which would stay as is). 
> 
> Picks would still be made on M, W, F, with no picks on weekends. The pre-draft, 
> pick-by-pick phase would be unchanged. 
> 
> Rounds 1 and 2 would each be divided into three 8-pick tiers.
> Rounds 3 through 7 would be divided into two 12-pick tiers. 
> Round 8 would remain a 24-pick list.
> Round 9 and later would remain combined as one list.
> 
> To accomplish this, list drafting would start approximately two weeks before it 
> does now and end at approximately the same time. The draft would begin on the 
> third Monday in January. Depending on where the third Monday falls, the draft 
> would run from January 15 through February 26 at the earliest and from January 
> 21 through March 2 at the latest.
> 
> The Commissioner would have discretion to convert more rounds from 12-pick to 
> 8-pick tiers depending on how far the pick-by-pick phase progresses. For every 
> 8-pick tier finished in the pick-by-pick phase, an additional round can be 
> converted from 12-pick tiers to 8-pick tiers without affecting the overall 
> draft calendar. 
> 
> ================================================================================
> INJURIES
> 
> (1)
> If a player's card has DL days above 0 and has already served as many or more 
> than his DL days, add 2 to his durability rating prior to rolling for additional 
> injury and days missed. The durability rating is modified 
> only once per season, and a player's modified durability range cannot exceed 8.  
> (Possible alternative version: once a player has served more than his DL days, 
> any subsequent 100% injury becomes 50% instead.)
> 
> (2)
> Track injuries concurrently (so in effect, if a player has two 100% injuries in 
> the same week, it would be similar to having one 100% injury.)
> Reasoning: if a player suffers two injuries in a real MLB game or series, he 
> doesn't have to wait for one of them to heal before beginning to recover from 
> the other injury.  Currently we add the duration of the injuries.
> 
> ================================================================================
> ROSTERS
> 
> (1)
> Increase the active roster to 27 or 28.  Reasoning: MLB clubs can activate and
> deactivate players after every game, so when they begin a series, they 
> effectively have a larger roster of players to use.  This would give IBL teams 
> similar flexibility, and be especially helpful when a series has unexpected 
> injuries or extra inning games. As a side benefit it may reduce the number of 
> activations/deactivations needed after each week, making it easier to manage 
> rosters and reduce work for the registrar.
> 
> (2)
> This proposal was voted down in 2016, and would be reproposed:
> 
> 2016-01) Allow teams to make in-series pitcher transactions due to extra 
> innings or double-headers
> 
> add section 4.1.2:
> 
> 4.1.2  Special Pitcher Activations
> 
> A team may replace pitcher(s) on the active roster with pitcher(s) on the
> inactive roster after any game that extends beyond the 9th inning, after the
> completion of a suspended game played on the same day as another game, or
> anytime during a series with a double-header (including between DH games). 
> Any pitcher activated in this fashion must have been eligible to be activated 
> for the current week (as per 3.2.2).
> 
> Teams may not sign free agents in this situation, only players on the
> inactive roster at the start of the series are eligible replacements.
> Special transactions should be reported with the GRS for the series.
> Players deactivated in this manner must remain inactive for the next two
> weeks, just as if they were deactivated after the conclusion of the series.
> 
> ================================================================================
> TRADING
> 
> (1)
> Proposed amendment in section 4.2:
> Trades may be made from December 1 until the newsletter following week 23.
> 
> And add to section 4.2.1
> During the list portion of an in-progress free agent draft, draft picks for 
> that year can only be traded prior to the list deadline set by the draft 
> administrator.
> 
> My idea is to maybe encourage people to trade up and down picks in the later 
> rounds in the days leading up to each draft list round.
> 
> ================================================================================
> MISCELLANEOUS
> 
> (1)
> Goal:
> Limit pitchers unrealistically pitching a long time fatigued.
> 
> Proposal:
> A pitcher may only face 9 batters while fatigued and then must be removed,
> unless no other pitchers are available.
> 
> Reasoning: This will still allow owners the flexibility to get their pitchers 
> some extra usage, or eat a couple innings to save the bullpen, but prevent
> ludicrous situations like a bad pitcher being left in to get destroyed for the 
> whole game.  This would never be allowed to occur in a real game, it is a kind
> of exploit of our usage requirements, and it results in ugly blowouts.
> 
> ================================================================================
> 
> -Rusty
> 
> 
> 

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.ibl.org/pipermail/members/attachments/20220828/c1b1d3a5/attachment.htm>